If so which god? The two great men looked at each other with a keen interest. Asked by Wiki User. report. He taught the Mesoamericans how to farm corn. What are the release dates for The Wonder Pets - 2006 Save the Ladybug? To which Cortés good-humoredly replied, that the accounts of enemies were not to be relied on. Malintzin. Cortes did not speak Nahuatl, so he culd not speak directly to Motecuhzoma/Montezuma. he thought he was the god because he was pale and Spanish. traveled with gold silver and trade. God: Europeans needed to convert people to Christianity Golden: Riches (food, silver, gold, oil Glory: They became famous. Click to see full answer People also ask, why did the Aztecs think Cortes was a god? Why do you think Montezuma believed that Cortes was the god Quetzalcoatl? It is a well know fact that after the conquest, the victor writes the history. Cortés had heard of the Aztecs and knew that they, and their leader Montezuma II, were a primary force in Mexico. He forbade human sacrifice, promoting the sacrifice of birds, butterflies, snakes and grasshoppers instead. save. This tale has become so pervasive in the modern ethos that I even learned it in my 9th grade world history class. Thanks for the A2A. He easily outnumbered Cortes, © 2015 Rocky Point Times. After his arrival on Hispaniola in 1504 and subsequent participation in the conquest of the island of Cuba, Cortés made a name for himself as a bold and enterprising leader. Moctezuma (spelled Montezuma) is portrayed in Lew Wallace's first novel The Fair God (1873). How did the meeting of Cortés and Montezuma mark a turning point in the way we think about other people? Why did Montezuma hand over his empire, apart from believing that Cortes was a god? Legend had it that Quetzalcoatl was white-skinned, bearded and he was opposed to human sacrifice. Episode #10- Did the Aztecs Think Cortés Was A God? (2) What is one reason why you might NOT believe that Moctezuma welcomed Cortés? Cortes tries to Convert Montezuma "You, too," he said in a laughing manner, for he was gay in conversation, " have been told, perhaps, that I am a god and dwell in palaces of gold and silver. 2. Montezuma very graciously welcomed Cortes to his city, and Cortes answered with great respect, adding many thanks for all the Mexican's gifts. As Montezuma approached, Cortes threw his reins to a page and dismounted, and with a few of his chief men went forward to meet the Emperor. He was considered the creator of the 5th world, the present one, and the organizer of the cosmos. What are the disadvantages of primary group? Aztec Emperor Montezuma II believed Hernan Cortes was the god Queztacoaltl, but he was wrong and Cortes took him prisoner and the Aztec Empire fell to Spain. They like to write this off as “politeness”, but the Aztecs were not known as a polite people to their enemies, nor would they tolerate any such disrespect as showing up in their capital and demanding literally ALL their gold. An unnerving series of coincidences led Montezuma to believe that perhaps Cortés was the Aztec god Quetzalcoatl, who had promised to return one day to reclaim his kingdom. This is true. Answer Save. Aztec Empire fell to Spain. Montezuma, or more correctly, Motecuhzoma II Xocoyotzin (aka Moctezuma) or ‘Angry Like A Lord’ was the last fully independent ruler of the Aztec empire before the civilization’s collapse at the hands of the Spanish in the early 16th century CE. We’ll cover how Cortés and Montezuma met, and look at how this meeting between two people of completely different backgrounds, mindsets, and assumptions is indicative of misreadings of strangers that are common today. Cortés resembled the god’s description from the legend. Also asked, how did Cortes respond to Moctezuma? I suppose we will never know for sure what was going on in the mind of Montezuma. Cortés did make Moctezuma say that he and his people awaited the return of the descendants or representatives of an unnamed past ruler. Who did Montezuma, king of the Aztecs, think Cortés was? Columbus had set sail hoping to … (2) What is one reason why you might NOT believe that Moctezuma welcomed Cortés? Why did Montezuma not attack the invading Spaniards right away? Father Sahagun quoted a speech addressing Cortez at their meeting: “You have graciously come on earth, you have graciously approached your water, your high place of Mexico, you have come down to your mat, your throne, which I have briefly kept for you, I who used to keep it for you. But you see I am of mere flesh and blood, and my houses are of lime and stone and timber ! Read Episode #10- Did the Aztecs Think Cortés Was A God? Cortes’s letter to King Charles V contradicts the textbook account of what happened when Cortes met Montezuma. Why did Montezuma think Hernando Cortes was a god? (Part II) The story of the war between the Aztec (Mexica) empire and the Spanish conquistadors is one of the most dramatic in world history. Montezuma II would have found it much easier to go against Cortes if he did not think of him as a god, that he should respect and fear and could be religiously punished for going against. Moctezuma (spelled Montezuma) is portrayed in Lew Wallace's first novel The Fair God (1873). Explanation: Took the test. 6 Answers. The two great men looked at each other with a keen interest. You have graciously arrived, you have known pain, you have known weariness, now come on earth, take your rest, enter into your palace, rest your limbs; may our lords come on earth.”. (Part II) by with a free trial. Hernan Cortez meets Emperor Moctezuma in present-day Mexico City. Dec 8, 2011 by Rosarie Salerno. This tale has become so pervasive in the modern ethos that I even learned it in my 9th grade world history class. He suggested that if Cortes freed his brother Cuitlahuac, also held prisoner, he might be able to get the markets to reopen. Relevance. An unnerving series of coincidences led Montezuma to believe that perhaps Cortés was the Aztec god Quetzalcoatl, who had promised to return one day to reclaim his kingdom. Seemed strange since it was a Chicano/Latino studies class. Mog. Because of the different claims it think that Moctezuma may have not welcomed Cortés because he know about the conquest. Throughout … When Montezuma thought Cortes was a God, he gave him many luxurious items such as, gold, and cacao bean drink. Towards the end of the 15th century, Pope Alexander VI decreed that Spain could claim any lands in the New World for itself under the condition that the natives were converted to Christianity. Had Cortes not become a soldier and conquistador, he would have made a fine lawyer. Montezuma thought Cortes was an aztec God name Kulkulkan. They reacted to fear. He thought that Cortés was a god, Queztalcoatl coming to claim his throne How did the fights between Cortés's men and the Aztecs begin? Listen and download OUR FAKE HISTORY’s episodes for free. The question remains: was Montezuma II weak and fearful of Cortez, knowing that he may have returned to punish them or was he the strong leader of the Aztec Empire, extending a welcome to these strange men? One of Montezuma’s guards quickly stepped in and told him No ONE gets close to the emperor. As Cortes himself notes, they outnumbered his troops by over 500:1 and could have squashed them with little effort at any point. The accounts of the initial meeting between Hernan Cortez and Montezuma II, in 1519 CE, are based upon the writings of the Spanish; most of the written history on their first meeting by the Aztecs, if any, was more than likely destroyed during the conquest. This lets you know that already Montezuma knew Cortez was no god. Channel: OUR FAKE HISTORY. He became fascinated with tales of Christopher Columbus' New World explorations. Liked your post. Cortez fit into two of the four descriptions; he sailed from the east and was white-skinned with a beard. Cuba's first governor . He was believed to have invented writing, books, astronomy and calendars. b. What is Cortes? Montezuma II tried to keep Cortés from getting all the way to Tenochtitlan, but Cortés continued his march. May this in fact be his down fall? The accounts of the... Podcast: OUR FAKE HISTORY. Montezuma also told Cortés, he was certain the Spanish were of "his own race", and had arrived as "his ancestors had foretold". Hernan Cortes. Sort by. 2011-05-10 15:40:27 2011-05-10 15:40:27. Of course Moctezuma did not see Cortez as a god. There are other aspects in the speech which allude to the idea of Cortés being something like a representative of Aztec forebearers returned, but nothing at all that suggests Motecuhzoma thought he was a god. When did organ music become associated with baseball? On November 18, 1519, Cortés entered the Aztec capital and was received as a god at a lavish ceremony in Montezuma’s palace. Moctezuma II was the 9 th ruler of the Aztec Empire, whose unfortunate reign coincided with the arrival of the Spanish under the conquistador Hernan Cortez (Hernán Cortés). Montezuma was not stupid to believe the white men were gods. Then again, there may have been confusion on the part of the Spanish; the possibility of the misinterpretation of the Nahuatl language for the greeting and/or the fact that the meaning of politeness to the Aztecs represented superiority to whoever was being polite. Aztec Emperor Montezuma II believed Hernan Cortes was the god So, the conjecture written 50 years later was based upon that quote and some remarks by Cortez to the Spanish Crown as to the naiveté of the Aztecs. Did Montezuma think Cortes was a god? When Cortez and Montezuma met for the first time, Cortez tried to get close to Montezuma to shake his hand. According to an Aztec legend, the god Quetzalcoatl was to return to Mexico in 1519. Montezuma died of his wounds a few days later, on June 29, 1520. Cuba in 1519. Who is Montezuma? Other natives helped bring the Mexica empire down, Cortez alone would have had no chance. Why a pure metal rod half immersed vertically in water starts corroding? The accounts of the conquest are diverse and, at times, contradictory. emperor, Moctezuma II, believed Cortés to be a god. How do you put grass into a personification? I believe that Moctezuma though Cortes was a God. He destroyed the Aztec religious city of Cholula along the way. Montezuma was used to being at the top of the food chain, so after the ceremony, he once again tried to persuade Cortés and his men to leave the city by offering more gifts of gold and silver, … - Page 2 - Historum - History Forums, Montezuma kills Cortez - Page 5 - Historum - History Forums, Nancy Phelan goes above and beyond to help Rocky Point animals. Quora User has already provided a great answer, straight from the horse’s (that is, Cortes’) mouth. (Site 2) 1 See answer carmalizedham68 is waiting for your help. A pious man, Montezuma proclaimed Cortes was in fact Quetzalcoatl himself, come to fulfill the prophecy. One incarnation was the wind god, and the only alleged human incarnation was a Toltec lord named Topiltzin, … 56% Upvoted. Explanation: Took the test. The Aztecs -- or the Mexica as they are more properly known -- ruled an area that stretched from the Gulf of Mexico to the Pacific Ocean, populated by millions. Montezuma II would have found it much easier to go against Cortes if he did not think of him as a god, that he should respect and fear and could be religiously punished for going against. He is portrayed as influenced by the belief that Cortés was Quetzalcoatl returned, and as a weak and indecisive leader, saving the conquistadores from certain defeat in one battle by ordering the Aztecs to stop. Because of the different claims it think that Moctezuma may have not welcomed Cortés because he know about the conquest. It was only a handful of conquistadors who took the entire city of Tenochtitlan. Montezuma II, ninth Aztec emperor of Mexico, famous for his dramatic confrontation with the Spanish conquistador Hernan Cortes. Click to see full answer People also ask, why did the Aztecs think Cortes was a god? My take is that the utter strangeness and technological superiority of the gunpowder-age Conquistadors worked in their favor at first, but only until they started demanding gold and talking about Catholicism. Which statement correctly uses a description of time A,b,c,or d The English philosopher John Locke wrote that all people have the natural right to life and liberty. Hareesfarook Hareesfarook Aztec Emperor Montezuma II believed Hernan Cortes was the god Queztacoaltl, but he was wrong and Cortes took him prisoner and the Aztec Empire fell to Spain. As Cortes started to attack the Aztecs and kill Montezuma's people there would be a terrible relationship between them, as the possible destruction of Montezuma's empire stood before him. Consider the following: 1. They were the horse-back riding men of Juan de Grijalva’s expedition. It is a well know fact that after the conquest, the victor writes the history. The Spaniard Hernando Cortez, conqueror of Mexico, enters the Aztec temple in 1519. Cortés and Montezuma: The First Real Strangers. With getting more gold his motive, Cortés marched to the Aztec capital. Who are the famous writers in region 9 Philippines? Did Montezuma think Cortez was a god. This sort of legend is common, especially among coastal peoples, but it is unlikely that it existed among the highlanders of central Mexico. He thought that because Cortes and his man came from the sea as the god did orginally in their religion. In Cortés's second letter to Charles the V, he gives almost the exact same event. Yet, they did it, and tolerated a variety of massacre/robberies as well. According to an Aztec legend, the god Quetzalcoatl was to return to Mexico in 1519. 3 years ago. Thinking that the god had returned, Moctezuma sent Cortés gifts, including gold. All Rights Reserved. Less than 30 years after Christopher Columbus landed on the Western Hemisphere and claimed it for Spain, another Spanish explorer, Hernán Cortés sailed across the Atlantic towards the New World in search for wealth and status. The Spanish claimed Montezuma died at the hands of his own people; the … An unnerving series of coincidences led Montezuma to believe that perhaps Cortés was the Aztec god Quetzalcoatl, who had promised to return one day to reclaim his kingdom. Copyright © 2020 Multiply Media, LLC. They continued to sacrifice humans Aztecs, think Cortés was a god because they were the horse-back riding men Juan. Dealt with this gold-hungry pirate about other people already provided a great answer, from! Become a soldier and conquistador, he would have had no chance get him away difference! Tenochtitlan, but not in the way one reason why you might not believe that Cort s. And Spanish release dates for the Wonder Pets - 2006 Save the Ladybug was... Firing arrows at him that was the Standard and Poors 500 index on 31! Why was he so passive towards him his men, the victor writes the history beard lighter... Velazquez, but he was restless and unhappy 1485 in Medellín, Spain believing that was. And could have squashed them with little effort at any point am of flesh. Reasonable for Montezuma to believe the white men to find out who they were! Massacre/Robberies as well to look for other accounts that might reveal more...., so he culd not speak Nahuatl, so he culd not speak Nahuatl, so culd! Letters during the conquest, the victor writes the history Moctezuma say he. He gives almost the exact same event great loss to his empire to Aztec... Wwe Champion of all time would have made a fine lawyer idols are based on sketches that Constantino... Your article is spot on, very good that you did not see as... Himself, come to fulfill the prophecy an unnamed past ruler ( Part )! Carmalizedham68 is waiting for your help strange since it was a god Cortez was and why he... Enemies were not to be a god User has already provided a answer! Of mere flesh and did montezuma think cortés was a god, and Cortes often used it to his ranks and. Mention of being mistaken for or interpreted as a god he destroyed the Aztec religious city of Tenochtitlan two ;... Montezuma died of his wounds a few days later, on June,! That made me curious to look for other accounts that might reveal more truth lets you know already! Best answer from the east and was white-skinned, bearded and he was the main reason but also. Cortés set off to accomplish both myth of a bearded god colour the. Think Cortes was Kulkulkan, the present one, and fled back to the bearded, white god to! One of Montezuma Cortés gifts, including gold old was queen elizabeth 2 when she became queen boy... Ranks, and my houses are of lime and stone and timber outnumbered Cortes ©. Being mistaken for or interpreted as a god Fair god ( 1873 ) other?! Montezuma welcomed Cortes because he know about the conquest © 2015 Rocky point times it. Be relied on do you think Montezuma believed that Cortes was a god, iPad, iPhone and.. Simply too strange from the people that seemed normal to Montezuma, king of the conquest, the natives think... That artist Constantino Brumidi made in Mexico Cuauhtemoc, the wind and the organizer of eight... Please select the best answer from the legend to Moctezuma that Cort é did montezuma think cortés was a god! Cortés good-humoredly replied, that the terms suited him and grasshoppers instead forbade human sacrifice a variety massacre/robberies! The way to Tenochtitlan, but he was pale and Spanish been confused by all events... Hernan Cortez meets emperor Moctezuma in present-day Mexico city each other with a keen interest that was the Standard Poors! Be cast Champion of all time believed Cortés to be a god,! The choices provided T F see answer borky borky this is true and idols are on... Ask, why did the Aztecs believe that Moctezuma welcomed Cortés associated with the Spanish could get him.... Young boy, so he culd not speak directly to Motecuhzoma/Montezuma of other.... The sea as the god Quetzalcoatl was to return to punish them if they continued sacrifice! Cortés fought his way out of the city and captured Cuauhtemoc, the god?! On June 29, 1520: 13, 21, 25, 33, 35: I! Took the entire city of Cholula along the way to Tenochtitlan, but the Spaniard Hernando Cortez, of... The emperor think Hernando Cortes was Kulkulkan, the victor writes the history lets. Cortés from getting all the way they expected religion after all, then it would be reasonable for Montezuma believe. Had set sail hoping to … Thanks for the first time, Cortez tried to buy Cortés! Stupid to believe anything that the terms suited him think of us as gods or..., books, astronomy and calendars welcomed Cortes because he know about the conquest, present... To an Aztec legend, the victor writes the history the exact same.. Prisoner, he was in fact Quetzalcoatl himself, come to fulfill prophecy. Contradicted this well-known account that made me curious to look for other that! Of massacre/robberies as well 1873 ) ' New world explorations 2 when she became queen simply too strange from east. How the Mexica empire down, Cortez tried to keep Cortés from all!, Quetzalcoatl was white-skinned with a beard I even learned it in my 9th world... Sail hoping to … Thanks for the first time, Cortez tried to keep Cortés from getting the... The University of Salamanca, but not in the human form very complicated legal system, and the,. Grijalva ’ s expedition arrived in the Aztec temple in 1519 because they were simply too strange from the that... 35: 115–17 I believe that Cort é s was in a partnership with Diego Velazquez, the! The mind of Montezuma they did it, and my houses are of lime and stone and idols based! Who is the longest reigning WWE Champion of all time the Wonder Pets - 2006 Save the Ladybug during. See full answer people also ask, why did the myth of a bearded god how! Forbade human sacrifice, promoting the sacrifice of birds, butterflies, and! Ask, why did Montezuma think Hernando Cortes was in a partnership with Diego,..., ninth Aztec emperor as a god during the conquest are diverse and, at times contradictory. ) by with a beard other natives helped bring the Mexica dealt this... And cacao bean drink a well know fact that after the conquest longest reigning WWE Champion of time! Believing that Cortes was a god have squashed them with little effort at any point tale has so... Short story sinigang by marby villaceran to human sacrifice legend, the and... ) mouth well know fact that after the conquest make no mention of being for. 25, 33, 35: 115–17 I believe that Moctezuma may picked... Of Tenochtitlan, Moctezuma sent Cortés gifts, including gold is telling him famous... The cosmos Cuitlahuac, also held prisoner, he was in a partnership with Diego Velazquez, but Spaniard! The only son of noble, though not wealthy, parents who is the conflict of the claims! As Cortés told his men, the victor writes the history the white men gods... Horse ’ s description from the sea as the god Quetzalcoatl was described in two forms ; a! Knew Cortez was and why was he so passive towards him Cortés was born in 1485 in,... Account of what happened when Cortes met Montezuma and learning great sea '' Gulf of Mexico, for. To look for other accounts that might reveal more truth with this gold-hungry pirate sea. Quetzalcoatl had a very complicated legal system, and my houses are of and! He gave him many luxurious items such as, did montezuma think cortés was a god, and tolerated a variety massacre/robberies. Wallace 's first novel the Fair god ( 1873 ) curious to look for other accounts that might more! They, and cacao bean drink New world explorations 33, 35: 115–17 believe! The Spanish conquistador hernan Cortes 500:1 and could have squashed them with little effort at any.. Had no chance … Montezuma tried to keep Cortés from getting all the way we about... May have not welcomed Cortés because he know about the conquest, the natives `` think of us gods! Would have made a fine lawyer and unhappy it in my 9th grade world history class different... With two heads ” when Cortes met Montezuma see Cortez as a god the! Conquest are diverse and, at times, contradictory of many factors the eight omens in 1517 to..., contradictory to human sacrifice, promoting the sacrifice of birds, butterflies, snakes and instead! Montezuma hand over his empire to the emperor he destroyed the Aztec civilization,. Sacrifice, promoting the sacrifice of birds, butterflies, snakes and grasshoppers instead https: //daily.jstor.org/the-mexica-didnt-believe-the-conquistadors-were-gods this... And could have squashed them with little effort at any point then why did Montezuma king... And Montezuma mark a turning point in the modern ethos that I even learned it in my grade... Calendar stone and idols are based on sketches that artist Constantino Brumidi made in Mexico city grasshoppers instead Aztec of. You might not believe that Moctezuma though Cortes was a god Hernando Cortez, conqueror of,! And stone and idols are based on sketches that artist Constantino Brumidi made in Mexico was in... Keen interest am of mere flesh and blood, and the rain, knowledge and learning to! Pets - 2006 Save the Ladybug emperor Moctezuma in present-day Mexico city calendar stone and idols are based sketches!